HOF Non-Players
UPDATED: 4/21/2024 thanks to rejuvenating this list at the 2024 Strongsville show!
@ = incoming
**I'm looking to obtain the earliest card possible of each card. The goal is to slowly work back and get the RC in the nicest possible condition. However, with pre war cards, I'll take whatever I can for the time being, if that means a 1990 Pacific or 1961 Fleer card, until I can obtain a card from their playing years.
ALSTON, WALTER - ANY from 1952 to 1959
ANDERSON, SPARKY - 1959 Topps RC only
BARLICK, AL - 1955 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher only
BARROW, ED - NEED 1950 Callahan HOF RC only
BULKELEY, MORGAN - 1908 George E. Wright Postcard in PSA/SGC 3 or higher only
CARTWRIGHT, ALEXANDER - ANY from 1880 to 1949
CHADWICK, HENRY - ANY from 1870 to 1949
CHANDLER, HAPPY - ANY from 1949 to 2023
CHYLAK, NESTOR - 1955 Bowman RC PSA 5 or higher only
COMISKEY, CHARLES - ANY from 1887 to 2023
CONLAN, JOCKO - 1931 La Presse RC or U2 1935-36 Diamond Matchbook Cover only
CONNOLLY, TOM - ANY from 1950 to 2023
COX, BOBBY - ANY from 1967 to 1977
CUMMINGS, CANDY - 1939-43 Sepia HOF PC or 1944-52 Albertype PC only
DREYFUSS, BARNEY - ANY from 1910 to 2023
DUROCHER, LEO - ANY from 1921 to 1950
EVANS, BILLY - ANY from 1910 to 2023
FRICK, FORD - ANY from 1949 to 2023
GILES, WARREN - 1956 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher only
GILLICK, PAT - ANY from 1997 to 2023
GRIFFITH, CLARK - ANY from 1889 to 1949
HANLON, NED - ANY from 1886 to 2023
HARRIDGE, WILLIAM - 1956 Topps RC only
HARRIS, BUCKY - 1921-23 E220 National Caramel HOF RC - DONE!
HARVEY, DOUG - ANY from 1984 to 2023
HERZOG, WHITEY - 1957 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher only
HUBBARD, CAL - 1933 Diamond Matchbook Cover RC only
HUGGINS, MILLER - ANY from 1906 to 1990
HULBERT, WILLIAM - ANY from 1994 to 2023
JOHNSON, BAN - ANY from 1906 to 2023
KLEM, BILL - ANY from 1910 to 1985
KUHN, BOWIE - ANY from 1969 to 2023
LANDIS, KENESAW - NEED 1929 Men of America HOF RC or 1944-52 Albertype PC only
LARUSSA, TONY - 1964 Topps RC PSA 6 or higher only
LASORDA, TOMMY - 1954 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher only
LOPEZ, AL - ANY from 1930 to 1952
MACK, CONNIE - ANY from 1887 to 1990
MacPHAIL, LARRY - ANY from 1973 to 2023
MacPHAIL, LEE - ANY from 1980 to 2023
McCARTHY, JOE - ANY from 1909 to 1990
McGOWAN, BILL - ANY from 1949 to 2023
McGRAW, JOHN - ANY from 1894 to 1949
McKECHNIE, BILL, ANY from 1911 to 1990
MILLER, MARVIN - ANY from 1994 to 2023
O'DAY, HANK - ANY from 1887 to 2023
O'MALLEY, WALTER - ANY from 1966 to 2023
RICKEY, BRANCH - ANY from 1914 to 2023
ROBINSON, WILBERT - ANY from 1887 to 1949
RUPPERT, JACOB - 1962 Topps RC #136 (w/ Ruth) PSA 6 or higher only
SCHUERHOLZ, JOHN - ANY from 1982 to 2023
SELEE, FRANK - ANY from 1904 to 2023
SELIG, BUD - ANY from 1994 to 2023
SOUTHWORTH, BILLY - ANY from 1916 to 1950
SPALDING, ALBERT - ANY from 1872 to 1949
STENGEL, CASEY - ANY from 1910 to 1957
TORRE, JOE - 1962 Topps RC PSA 6 or higher only
VEECK, BILL - ANY from 1948 to 2023
WEAVER, EARL - 1969 Topps RC only
WEISS, GEORGE - ANY from 1973 to 2023
WILLIAMS, DICK - 1950-51 Mejoral RC only
WRIGHT, GEORGE - ANY from 1863 to 1949
WRIGHT, HARRY - ANY from 1863 to 2023
YAWKEY, TOM - 1959 Fleer Ted Williams #42 HOF RC - DONE!