Post War HOF Rookies

UPDATED: 7/21/2025 thanks to WES SHEPARD for the '64T Stargell, '58T Mazeroski, '48L Kiner RC, and '58T Schoendienst!

@ = incoming

**Looking to obtain the oldest possible card I can get for each HOFer!

**If you are a VSP member, this is a great way to get a lot of chips!! Thanks!

"A" Needs

AARON, HANK: 1954 Topps RC PSA/SGC 1 or higher only

ALLEN, RICHIE: 1964 Topps RC PSA 4 or higher only

ALOMAR, ROBERTO: 1988 Score Traded RC PSA 9 or 10 only

APARICIO, LUIS: 1956 Topps RC PSA 3 or higher only

ASHBURN, RICHIE: ANY card from 1948 to 1953

"B" Needs

BAGWELL, JEFF: ANY card from 1988 to 1991

BAINES, HAROLD: 1981 Topps RC PSA 9 or 10 only

BANKS, ERNIE: 1954 Topps RC PSA/SGC 2 or higher only

BELTRE, ADRIAN: ANY card from 1997 to 2002

BENCH, JOHNNY: 1968 Topps RC PSA 7 or higher only

BERRA, YOGI: ANY card from 1947 to 1953

BIGGIO, CRAIG: 1988 Score Traded RC PSA 9 or 10 only

BLYLEVEN, BERT: 1971 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher

BOGGS, WADE: 1983 Topps RC only

BRETT, GEORGE: 1975 Topps RC only

BROCK, LOU: ANY card from 1962 to 1965

BUNNING, JIM: 1957 Topps RC PSA 2 or higher only

"C" Needs

CAMPANELLA, ROY: ANY card from 1949 to 1952

CAREW, ROD: 1967 Topps RC, 1967 Minnesota Team Issue RC, or 1968 Topps only

CARLTON, STEVE: ANY card from 1965 to 1967

CARTER, GARY: 1975 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher only

CEPEDA, ORLANDO: 1958 Topps RC only

CLEMENTE, ROBERTO: ANY from 1955 to 1960

"D" & "E" Needs

DAWSON, ANDRE: 1977 Topps RC PSA 4 or higher only

DOBY, LARRY: ANY from 1947 to 1953

DRYSDALE, DON: ANY from 1956 to 1958

ECKERSLEY, DENNIS: 1976 Topps RC PSA 6 or higher only

"F" Needs

FINGERS, ROLLIE: 1969 Topps RC only

FISK, CARLTON: 1972 Topps RC PSA/SGC 5 or higher only

FORD, WHITEY: 1951 Bowman RC or 1951 Berk Ross RC only

FOX, NELLIE: ANY from 1949 to 1957

"G" Needs

GIBSON, BOB: 1959 Topps RC only

GLAVINE, TOM: 1988 Score RC only

GOSSAGE, GOOSE: ANY card from 1972 to 1983

GRIFFEY, JR., KEN: 1989 Upper Deck RC only

GUERRERO, VLADIMIR: ANY card from 1995 to 2010

GWYNN, TONY: 1982 TCMA Hawaii or a 1983 Topps RC PSA 8 or higher

"H" & "I" Needs

HALLADAY, ROY: ANY card from 1997 or 1998

HELTON, TODD: 1993 Topps Traded RC only

HENDERSON, RICKEY: - 1977 Chong Modesto A's, 1979 TCMA Ogden, or 1980 Topps RC only

HODGES, GIL: ANY from 1949 to 1953

HOFFMAN, TREVOR: 1992 Bowman RC only

HUNTER, CATFISH: ANY from 1965 to 1968

IRVIN, MONTE: ANY from 1948 to 1953

"J" Needs

JACKSON, REGGIE: 1969 Topps RC PSA 3 or higher only!

JENKINS, FERGIE: ANY from 1966 to 1969

JETER, DEREK: 1993 SP Foil RC only

JOHNSON, RANDY: 1986 Pro Cards West Palm Beach, 1987 Pro Cards Jacksonville, or 1989 Upper Deck RC PSA 9 or 10 only

JONES, CHIPPER: 1991 Bowman RC PSA 9 or 10 only

"K" & "L" Needs

KAAT, JIM: 1960 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher only

KALINE, AL: 1954 Topps RC SGC/PSA 2 or higher only

KELL, GEORGE: ANY card from 1945 to 1952

KILLEBREW, HARMON: ANY card from 1955 to 1958

KINER, RALPH: 1948 Leaf RC PSA/SGC 1.5 or higher only

KOUFAX, SANDY: 1955 Topps RC PSA/SGC 1.5 or higher

LARKIN, BARRY: 1986 Sportsflics or a 1987 Fleer RC PSA 9 or 10 only

LEMON, BOB: ANY from 1946 to 1949

"M" Needs

MADDUX, GREG: 1986 Pro Cards Pittsfield or a 1987 Donruss RC PSA 9 or 10 only

MANTLE, MICKEY: ANY card from 1951 to 1959

MARICHAL, JUAN: ANY card from 1960 to 1962

MARTINEZ, EDGAR: 1988 Fleer RC PSA 10 only

MARTINEZ, PEDRO: 1990 Sport Pro Great Falls or 1991 Upper Deck Final Edition RC PSA 9 or 10 only

MATHEWS, EDDIE: ANY card from 1952 or 1953

MAUER, JOE: ANY card from 2001 to 2005

MAYS, WILLIE: ANY card from 1951 to 1956

MAZEROSKI, BILL: 1957 Topps RC only

MCCOVEY, WILLIE: ANY card from 1960 to 1968

MCGRIFF, FRED: 1986 Donruss RC PSA 10 only

MINOSO, MINNIE: ANY card from 1945 to 1956

MOLITOR, PAUL: 1978 Topps RC PSA 6 or higher only

MORGAN, JOE: 1965 Topps RC PSA/SGC 4 or higher

MORRIS, JACK: 1978 Topps RC PSA 7 or higher only

MURRAY, EDDIE: 1977 Baltimore Team Issue, 1977 Baltimore Photo Album, 1978 Topps RC, or 1978 Kellogg's RC only

MUSIAL, STAN: ANY from 1943 to 1958

MUSSINA, MIKE: 1990 Classic Draft Picks or 1991 Ultra Update RC PSA 9 or 10 only

"N" & "O" Needs

NEWHOUSER, HAL: ANY card from 1939 to 1990

NIEKRO, PHIL: ANY from 1964 or 1965

OLIVA, TONY: 1963 Topps RC or 1964 Topps only

ORTIZ, DAVID: 1997 Ultra Fleer RC

"P" Needs

PAIGE, SATCHEL: ANY card from 1948 to 1988

PALMER, JIM: ANY card from 1965 to 1969

PARKER, DAVE: ANY card from 1974 or 1975

PEREZ, TONY: 1963 San Diego Team Issue, 1964 Cincinnati Team Issue, or 1965 Topps RC only

PERRY, GAYLORD: 1962 Topps RC PSA/SGC 2 or higher only

PIAZZA, MIKE: 1989 Salem Dodgers, 1990 Star Vero Beach, or 1992 Fleer Update RC only

PUCKETT, KIRBY: 1983 Larry Fritsch Visalia Oaks, 1984 Fleer Update, 1984 Minnesota Team Issue, or 1984 O'Connell & Son Ink RCs only

"R" Needs

RAINES, TIM: 1981 Topps RC PSA 9 or 10 only

RICE, JIM: 1975 Topps RC PSA 6 or higher only

RIPKEN, JR., CAL: ANY card from 1980 or 1981, or a 1982 Topps RC PSA 8 or higher

RIVERA, MARIANO: 1990 Diamond Cards Tampa, 1991 Pro Cards Greensboro, or 1992 Bowman RC only

ROBERTS, ROBIN: ANY card from 1948 to 1958

ROBINSON, BROOKS: ANY card from 1957 to 1960

ROBINSON, FRANK: 1957 Topps RC only

ROBINSON, JACKIE: ANY card from 1946 to 1990

RODRIGUEZ, IVAN: 1991 Ultra RC PSA 9 or 10 only

ROLEN, SCOTT: 1995 Bowman's Best RC only

RYAN, NOLAN: 1968 Topps RC PSA/SGC 3 or higher only!

"S" Needs

SABATHIA, CC: ANY from 1999 to 2001

SANDBERG, RYNE: ANY card from 1980 to 1982, or a 1983 Topps RC only

SANTO, RON: 1961 Topps RC PSA 4 or higher only

SCHMIDT, MIKE: ANY card from 1972 to 1980

SCHOENDIENST, RED: ANY card from 1945 to 1957

SEAVER, TOM: 1967 Topps RC only

SIMMONS, TED: 1971 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher only

SMITH, LEE: 1982 Topps RC PSA 9 or 10 only

SMITH, OZZIE: ANY card from 1978 to 1983

SMOLTZ, JOHN: 1986 Pro Cards Lakeland, 1987 Pro Cards Glen Falls, 1988 Fleer Update or 1988 Fleer Update Glossy RC only

SNIDER, DUKE: ANY card from 1947 to 1953

SPAHN, WARREN: ANY card from 1946 to 1953

STARGELL, WILLIE: 1963 Topps RC only

SUTTER, BRUCE: 1977 Topps RC PSA 7 or higher only

SUTTON, DON: ANY from 1966 or 1967

SUZUKI, ICHIRO: ANY 2001 RC

"T" Needs

THOMAS, FRANK: 1987 BDK Team USA, 1988 Cape Cod League, 1990 Topps NO NAME, or 1990 Leaf RC only

THOME, JIM: 1990 Pro Cards Burlington or 1991 Bowman RC only

TRAMMELL, ALAN: 1978 Topps RC PSA 6 or higher only

"W" Needs

WAGNER, BILLY: ANY from 1994 to 1996

WALKER, LARRY: 1990 Leaf RC PSA 10 only

WILHELM, HOYT: ANY from 1950 to 1953

WILLIAMS, BILLY: 1961 Topps RC PSA 4 or higher only

WINFIELD, DAVE: 1973 Dean's Photo Service or 1974 Topps RC PSA 5 or higher

WYNN, EARLY: ANY card from 1943 to 1958

"Y" Needs

YASTRZEMSKI, CARL: ANY card from 1960 or 1961

YOUNT, ROBIN: ANY card from 1975 or 1976

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse