HOF Non-Players

UPDATED: 11/20/2025 thanks to updating my list!

@ = incoming

**Looking to obtain the oldest possible card I can get for each HOFer!

** There are likely many cards missing from this list. I'm constantly updating this list as time permits! :)

"A" & "B" Needs

ALSTON, WALTER: ANY card from 1936 to 1960

ANDERSON, SPARKY: ANY card from 1958 to 1971

BARLICK, AL: 1955 Bowman RC only

BARROW, ED: 1950 Callahan HOF RC or 1953-55 Artvue HOF PC only

BULKELEY, MORGAN: 1870s-90s (1892?) Mathew Brady Cabinet, 1890 Connecticut National Guard at Camp Embler Cabinet, 1896 Whitehead & Hoag Pin RC only

"C" Needs

CARTWRIGHT, ALEXANDER: ANY card from the 1850s to 1961

CHADWICK, HENRY: 1870s Frank Pearsall Cabinet, 1939-43 HOF Sepia PC, 1944-52 Albertype PC, or 1950 Callahan HOF only

CHANDLER, HAPPY: ANY card from 1935 to 1961

CHYLAK, NESTOR: 1955 Bowman RC only

COMISKEY, CHARLES: ANY card from 1886 to 1961

CONLAN, JOCKO: 1931 La Presse RC only!

CONNOLLY, TOM: 1950 Callahan HOF or 1953-55 Artvue HOF PC only

COX, BOBBY: ANY card from 1967 to 1983

CUMMINGS, CANDY: ANY card from 1870 to 1961

"D", "E", "F", & "G" Needs

DREYFUSS, BARNEY: ANY card from 1910 to 1961

DUROCHER, LEO: ANY card from 1921 to 1969

EVANS, BILLY: 1910 M101-2 Sporting News, 1922 W461 Exhibits, or 1961 Fleer only

FRICK, FORD: 1949 Eureka Sportstamps RC only

GILES, WARREN: 1956 Topps RC only

GILLICK, PAT: 1997 Canadian Hall of Fame RC only

GRIFFITH, CLARK: ANY card from 1889 to 1961

"H" Needs

HANLON, NED: ANY card from 1881 to 1961

HARRIDGE, WILLIAM: 1956 Topps RC only

HARRIS, BUCKY: ANY card from 1921 to 1990

HARVEY, DOUG: 1984 SD Padres "Smokey the Bear" RC only

HERZOG, WHITEY: ANY card from 1957 or 1958

HUBBARD, CAL: 1933 Diamond Matchbook Cover RC or 1955 Bowman only

HUGGINS, MILLER: ANY card from 1906 to 1978

HULBERT, WILLIAM: 1994 American Archives "Origins of Baseball" RC only

"J" & "K" Needs

JOHNSON, BAN: 1906 Fan Craze RC or 1909-13 M101-2 Sporting News only

KLEM, BILL: ANY card from 1910 to 1971

KUHN, BOWIE: 1969 Topps Promo or 1977 SD Padres Schedule Card only

"L" Needs

LANDIS, KENESAW: ANY card from 1911 to 1961

LARUSSA, TONY: ANY from 1964 to 1971

LASORDA, TOMMY: ANY card from 1950 to 1971

LEYLAND, JIM: 1975 TCMA Clinton Pilots, 1980 TCMA Evansville Triplets, 1981 TCMA Evansville Triplets, 1986 Topps Traded, or 1986 Topps Traded Tiffany RC only

LOPEZ, AL: ANY card from 1930 to 1960

"M" Needs

MACK, CONNIE: ANY card from 1887 to 1961

MacPHAIL, LARRY: 1973-80 TCMA ATG RC only

MacPHAIL, LEE: 1980-01 Perez Steele HOF PC only

McCARTHY, JOE: ANY card from 1909 to 2003

McGOWAN, BILL: 1949-50 Umpire School PC RC only

McGRAW, JOHN: ANY card from 1894 to 1961

McKECHNIE, BILL: ANY card from 1911 to 1961

MILLER, MARVIN: 1994 Upper Deck Ken Burns only

"O" & "R" Needs

O'DAY, HANK: ANY card from 1887 to 1961

O'MALLEY, WALTER: DONE! 1958 TIME Magazine

RICKEY, BRANCH: ANY card from 1914 to 1961

ROBINSON, WILBERT: ANY card from 1887 to 1971

RUPPERT, JACOB: DONE! 1962 Topps w/ Ruth

"S", "T", & "V" Needs

SCHUERHOLZ, JOHN: 1982 KC Royals Team Issue through 1985 KC Royals Team Issue only

SELEE, FRANK: 1904 Allegheny Card Company only

SELIG, BUD: 1994 NCC Top 4 Stories RC or 2006 Jewish Major Leaguers Update only

SOUTHWORTH, BILLY: ANY card from 1916 to 1958

SPALDING, ALBERT: ANY card from 1872 to 1961

STENGEL, CASEY: ANY card from 1910 to 1957

TORRE, JOE: 1961 LL Cook Company Postcard or ANY card from 1962

VEECK, BILL: ANY card from 1948 to 1961

"W" & "Y" Needs

WEAVER, EARL: 1967-69 Baltimore Team Issue or 1969 Topps RC only

WEISS, GEORGE: 1973-80 TCMA ATG RC PSA 5 or higher only

WILLIAMS, DICK: ANY card from 1950 to 1958

WRIGHT, GEORGE: ANY card from 1863 to 1961

WRIGHT, HARRY: ANY card from 1863 to 1961

YAWKEY, TOM: 1959 Fleer Ted Williams #42 RC only

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse